Elijah Edward Pinnance (1879–1944) was a Canadian Major League Baseball pitcher.
He played for the Philadelphia Athletics during the 1903 season.
Pinnance was the first full-blooded American Indian to play in a regular season game in the majors, which occurred on September 14, 1903.
At that time, Pinnance pitched for the Philadelphia Athletics at Washington against the Senators.
He played for the Albany Senators in 1906.